Translate

Saturday 31 January 2015

Enjoyment vs Discipline

When I reflect on my classroom experiences, I remember one interesting episode. The father of my student of class 7 came to meet me. I was teaching English. I was a bit surprised to see him, as he hardly came to school. He had a note book in his hand. He appeared angry. I, with my usual smile, asked what can I do for him. He sarcastically said ‘Don’t do anything for me, do for my daughter!!!’. He opened the note book and showed a English essay which I had marked in his daughter’s note book. He pointed towards my remark ‘excellent’, and asked, ‘Madam, did you go through the essay or just remarked? Her language is not up to the mark. She has made many grammatical errors. But still you call it excellent? You have not even underlined the errors.’ 

 I was unmoved by his confrontation. Again with a cool smile I explained to him. ‘Your daughter’s favourite subject is English. She loves to write, is the 1st person to finish any creative writing task. I want to nourish this passion of hers. Your daughter needs encouragement more than the exact rules of grammar or high standard language. If I highlight her mistakes and rob her love for the subject, she will never try to write independently. She may gradually pick up the rules, but will never regain her love for writing once she loses it.’ As I was speaking, the frowning eyebrows of the father slowly eased out.

I had realised that the real delight and encouragement are as much essential for enjoying learning as discipline was.  

7 comments:

  1. Amazing, Awesome encouragement madam, it's like saying when the mind is open everything else will follow automatically.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes Karthik, Free thinking is very important for growth..

      Delete
  2. That was a rather sensible thing to do :) The perfect way to ensure the students remain motivated to strive for perfection.

    (Btw, creating a blog to record all your experiences as a teacher was a fantastic idea ! We parents, who play the roles of teachers at home, can pick up some interesting tidbits on how to respond to children. Kudos to you ! Looking forward for more such posts).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. :) Thx for your comments Chandana. Yes that was the reason to start this blog. My students were insisting on blog writing since a long time. :)

      Delete
  3. I agree, at times encouragement let students grow and when they grow slowly we can tame them and make them concentrate on quality which is essence in itself for ones success.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for your observations Vinayak Shenoy

    ReplyDelete
  5. just too nice ... great .. hope more people understand this.

    ReplyDelete